According to the prosecution on the day of the murder, at around 7 am, Flowers walked from his home on the West side of town all the way to a sewing factory parking lot on the East side of town, crossing Highway 51, one of the towns largest streets, while doing so. 24 Federal Bureau of Investigation, Crime in the United States 2012: Persons Arrested,. Mahsa Amini, 22, died on September 16, three days after falling into a coma following her arrest, After the death of Mahsa Amini, Anti Iran protests have been held in many parts of the world. 14 Manson, 432 U.S. 98, 12526 (Marshall, J., dissenting). To date, 25 states have adopted these core procedural reforms, including Texas in 2011, one year after the investigation of Aaron Scheerhoorns murder. The person they think was the perpetrator in fact had nothing to do with the crime. Psychological scientists, however, have challenged many of the assumptions of the legal system and the general public regarding the. Today, he remains in prison. While 30+ years of research is too much to summarize in a few paragraphs, we will outline the general problems with eyewitness testimony as well as some of them more major research that has been performed on the subject. Compiled by Ann Njarara, Bree Peilen, Daniel Neuman, Emory Cook, Linda Lin, and Perrin Lowrey, Introduction
A meta-analytic review of the effects of high stress on eyewitness memory, Law and Human Behavior 28.6 (2004), 687-706. The reliability of these alleged identifications was suspect, since the officers would have had only a fraction of a second to observe the driver whizz by them at a high rate of speed at night. He claimed police did not have the power to use firearms in the riots. Expert witness evidence is not needed in all legal proceedings but it plays an important part in many cases. In Manson, the Supreme Court highlighted reliability as the linchpin in determining the admissibility of identification testimony and adopted a totality of the circumstances test to assess reliability in this context.10
Thanks for reading Scientific American. 27 The Innocence Project, Eyewitness Identification,. 31 Elizabeth Loftus, Eyewitness Science and the Legal System, 14 Annual Review of Law and Social Science 110 (2018). Following criticism of the decision, the high court ordered the parole board to re-examine Worboys case. But a closer examination of those witnesses testimonies reveals a few disconcerting factors: the earliest testimony from a witness came a month after the murders, and other testimony came nine, twelve months later. But studies demonstrate that a variety of factors can lead to the misidentification of criminals. My review of the transcripts from Grants trial suggests a simple explanation for these high-confidence mistakes: The police did not use scientific best practices for collecting the eyewitness identification evidence. Your details from Facebook will be used to provide you with tailored content, marketing and ads in line with our Privacy Policy. By the way, Weger signed EVERY SINGLE PAGE of the FIRST confession which was transcribed by a court reporter who testified under OATH Weger was not threatened or harmed when he made his damning statement. In recent years, more and more jurisdictions have come to accept expert testimony on the reliability of eyewitness identification. Why not be the first to send us your thoughts, With surprising ease, for example, participants in a memory experiment can be led to believe that they saw a stop sign when they actually saw a yield sign or that they became lost in a shopping mall as a child when no such experience actually occurred. (Sometimes there is an issue of racial bias connected with eyewitness misidentification, but this was not a factor as the parking lot attendants were also African American.). You can choose on each post whether you would like it to be posted to Facebook. In 1932, Yale University law professor Edwin M. Borchard documented nearly seventy cases of miscarriage of justice caused by eyewitness errors in his book, Convicting the Innocent.22
This is not always the case. Sally Challen claimed she experienced years of emotional abuse before killing him with a hammer. He did it and was fortunate not to be sentenced to death in that era. Noxious fumes wafted into their classrooms, causing some to need hospital treatment after complaining of headaches, heart palpitations, lethargy and being unable to move. In other words, the confirmatory remark made the mistaken eyewitnesses just as persuasive as the accurate ones. Current procedures for collecting and assessing evidence from eyewitnesses are often not designed to minimize contamination.This problem does not apply to other kinds of forensic evidence. Standardized instructions regarding best practices should be given, including such tips as the importance of minimizing contact between witnesses at the scene, and how gathering eyewitness testimony as early as possible tends to increase its accuracy. Examples of when an expert witness may be needed include: To hire an expert witness, you may make contact with us via our simple online contact form, call us on 01865 587 865 or by requesting a call back from our team via the link below. The shooter had borrowed Heidelbergs car, and when Heidelberg went to retrieve his car later that night he was arrested by officers at the scene. Daryl G. Kimball and Frank von Hippel | Opinion. Historically, eyewitness testimony has been in use not only in the United States and our penal system but all around the world. Please send suggestions to Mind Matters editor Gareth Cook. The Innocence Project found that out of 138 cases, two-thirds of the DNA exonerated cases were due to an eyewitness testimony (Howitt, 2012). In assessing the reliability of eyewitness identification, federal and state courts are still divided on (1) whether expert testimony on eyewitness identification should be allowed under either Daubert or Frye and (2) the proper exercise of trial court discretion when deciding whether to admit such expert testimony.18
Another stated that the killers face was burned into [her] memory immediately.. Yet, based on, among other things, this powerful purported eyewitness evidence, Heidelberg was convicted. He is the founder of Hale & Monico, Americas Justice Attorneys. 70 percent of the 349 wrongful convictions. Mugshots of Lydell Grant (left, in 2010) and Jermarico Carter (right, in 2007) show the men dont look very similar. 23 United States v. Wade, 388 U.S. 230, 288 (1967). What facts gave rise to the belief that Leiterman may have been wrongfully convicted based on contaminated evidence? bn. The witnesses trial testimony reveals a simple explanation for these high-confidence errors: All of the eyewitnesses received confirmatory feedback following their identification of Grant. In much the same way, an eyewitness can be led to falsely remember someone committing a crime that was actually committed by someone else. 'This is not the way to conduct an interview. This case raised important questions about the reliability of expert evidence. Family weapons were used to kill the victims in the Murdaugh case, prosecutor says Prosecutor Creighton Waters speaks during closing arguments on Wednesday, March 1. Perhaps one of the most striking examples of the flaws in eyewitness testimony is the case of Jerry Miller, who was convicted of rape, robbery and kidnapping in 1982. 28 Brandon L. Garrett, Convicting the Innocent: Where Criminal Prosecutions Go Wrong 6368 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2011). Judges in California routinely talk to jurors about the possibility of misidentification, but their instructions arent as complete as those contemplated by the New Jersey court. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
The NRCs recommendations for law enforcement and judges are below.32. EvgeniyShkolenko/iStock via Getty Images Plus, Chicago Sun-Times/Chicago Daily News/Chicago History Museum via Getty Images, Scientific best practices for conducting eyewitness lineups, smile when witnesses are looking at the suspect, no longer tell the difference between accurate and mistaken eyewitnesses, alter witnesses memories of the original crime, less able to recognize the actual perpetrator, is informative regarding the eyewitnesss accuracy, 25 states have adopted these core procedural reforms, Committee Member - MNF Research Advisory Committee, PhD Scholarship - Uncle Isaac Brown Indigenous Scholarship. Another way is through the misinformation effect, where something occurs between the event and the reporting of the event to muddy or confuse the witness. His doctors maintained that he was suffering from pre-senile dementia, and he couldnt remember three numbers backwards or the name of the US president. A neurologist also claimed that Saunders brain was small for a man his age and showed evidence of shrinking. They were then asked a leading question about how fast the car was going when it passed the yield sign. A cornerstone of the state's case is the video at or near the kennels filmed on Paul's phone starting at 8:44 p.m. in which Murdaugh's voice can be heard in the background. This evidence was not presented in the initial trial. Thirty Years of DNA Forensics: How DNA Has Revolutionized Criminal Investigations., See here: Innocence Project, Eyewitness misidentification, Crime in the United States 2012: Persons Arrested,. Its a fact that eyewitnesses make mistakes. If New Jersey can have statewide guidelines, so can California. Your comment will be posted to MailOnline as usual. Renowned Expert witnesses include doctors, psychologists, psychiatrists, social workers, and other professionals who are instructed to give expert opinions in legal proceedings. 5 Brewer & Treyens, Role of Schemata in Memory for Places, Cognitive Psychology 13.2 (1981). Some courts have held it as an abuse of discretion for a trial judge to bar the defense from admitting expert testimony on eyewitness identification. 'You're supposed to interview me but you're actually having a confrontation with me,' he told Amanpour. In one study, people playing the role of jurors were able to reliably distinguish between accurate and mistaken eyewitnesses when the witnesses had not received any confirmatory feedback. Medicolegal court reports are requested where expert witness evidence is required. This decision attracted intense media attention and was seen to be a controversial decision due to the nature and severity of his offences. The other individuals placed in a lineup with the suspect (known as fillers) are supposed to reasonably resemble the suspect in terms of age, height and weight so that the suspect does not stand out. More and more research has come out in the last few decades indicating that there are many dangers to relying on eyewitnesses, from the uncertainty of relying on a persons memory all the way to how they are questioned at the police station. Thomas D. Albright, director of the Vision Center Laboratory at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies, listed some of the many variables affecting eyewitness testimony in a 2017 paper published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, entitled Why Eyewitnesses Fail.. If a judge finds the eyewitness testimony unreliable, he can suppress its use at trial. Assessing confidence is critical because it provides direct information about the trustworthiness of the uncontaminated ID. However, there has yet to be research showing what ideal instructions would look like, as each case involving eyewitness testimony varies from each other. For example, in cases where a mental disorder is an issue, the evidence of a psychiatrist may influence the conduct of legal proceedings, it may help to adduce medical evidence relevant to trial and may be the deciding factor between imprisonment and mental health treatment. (2017). Carter has now been indicted for the murder by a grand jury, and Lydell Grant was released from prison. 'In Iran we had an incident. Similarly, a witness may mistakenly perceive the circumstances of a crime or event, such as a car accident. The Louisiana Supreme Court remanded the case based on prosecutorial and police misconduct, including improper argument at the trial and failure to disclose the existence of exculpatory witnesses. circuit court, the 29-year-old was convicted of a rape that he did not commit and was sentenced to five life sentences. 8 Clifford & Hollin, Effects Of the Type of Incident and the Number of Perpetrators on Eyewitness Memory, Journal of Applied Psychology 66.3 (1981). The lineup photo from one of these lineups shows how suggestive it was: The other four men in the lineup were much older and bigger than Chester. You have, Witnesses are Often Wrong: The Case Against Eyewitness ID, Florida City Creates Youth Curfew to Deter Juvenile Crime, Legislator Introduces Laws to Protect Law Enforcement After Temple University Cop is Killed in the Line of Duty, Oversight Report Shows Issues with DOJ Collection of Deaths in Policy Custody Data, Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License, New York-Based Chinese Gang Steals 3,000 Texas IDs in Cyber Fraud Case, Murdaugh Murder Trial Jurors to Visit Crime Scene, Heartbreakingly Evil: DOJ Strengthens Fight Against Elder Fraud, Sex Abuse of Athletes: Dont Tell is No Longer an Option, Criminal Justice Journalism Wins Pulitzer Prizes, View from the Trauma Center: Why Gun Violence Persists. After . Like eyewitness memory, DNA evidence can be contaminated with the trace of an innocent person. U. L. Rev. Here is a link to a general overview on eyewitness testimony from the National Science Foundation. Additional Reading: Truth, Lies and Police Lineups, The Crime Report, May 5, 2021. Improper lineup procedures can also lead to witness misidentifications. The first is in the classic My Cousin Vinny situation, where eyewitnesses simply believe they see something, despite not actually being capable of truly witnessing the event accurately. Confidence reported at trial after the eyewitness has received confirmatory feedback is not. Even though no connection between Leiterman and Ruelas was ever established, the prosecution theorized that all three must have been together after midnight at the murder scene in 1969, with the preschooler bleeding on the victim for some unknown reason while Leiterman killed her. Compared to administrators conducting double-blind lineups, these informed administrators are more likely to ask witnesses about the suspect and smile when witnesses are looking at the suspect rather than at another person in the lineup. Psychologists have learned a lot about why such errors happen. University of Virginia law professor Brandon Garrett analyzed trial materials for 161 DNA exonerated individuals who had been misidentified with high confidence by one or more eyewitnesses in a court of law. Prior to admitting eyewitness testimony, judges should make inquiries into the reliability of the eyewitness, looking for any indications of unreliability. Specifically, the eyewitness had identified the defendant from her window, as the defendant was standing in the dark next to a police officer; however, the eyewitness had pointed to the defendant spontaneously, without the police asking her to do so.16 The Court ruled that, because the police had not induced the identification under suggestive circumstances, the trial judge had not erred in admitting the eyewitness testimony without assessing its reliability under the second step of the Manson test.17
Such behaviors are often inadvertent; neither lineup administrators nor eyewitnesses may be consciously aware that theyre happening. Attributing that error to the unreliability of eyewitness memory is, in our view, pointing the finger of blame in the wrong direction. The murder victims cold case evidence was there because the case had recently been reopened; the 1969 preschoolers DNA sample was there as part of an active murder investigation, and Leitermans DNA sample was there because he had recently been arrested for forging a prescription. Retrieved March, 2019. In the sad case of the 1960 Starved Rock murders, there were EIGHT confessions by Chester Weger made to different people at different times, including a re-enactment of the crime at the scene covered by more than a dozen reporters/photographers. The way to avoid these problems with eyewitness testimony is for police to adopt best practices based on the psychological research. Finally, almost a year later, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals declared Grant actually innocent on May 19, 2021. There have been many famous expert witness cases. or debate this issue live on our message boards. Speak to our experts today for advice. "Double-Blind" Process for Lineups and Photo Arrays. The FBI estimates that 521,196 of these arrests were for violent crimes.24 Accurate data on the number of crimes observed by eyewitnesses are not available. In the Miller case, a. Despite the frequency of use, we have been confronted as a country with many incredible failures of eyewitness testimony such as misidentifications that led to convictions and sentences of people who were later discovered innocent.1 Science has played no small role: post-conviction DNA profiling made possible by the development of the polymerase chain reaction, which enables amplification of crime-scene DNA to quantities sufficient for forensic analysis have meant that DNA identification is becoming increasingly used even in cases where it was previously not viable: those where we have smaller samples.2 As of now, almost 350 people, many serving long prison sentences, have been exonerated because their own DNA was discovered to be incompatible with evidence long ago collected from the crime scene. Medicolegal court reports are requested where expert witness evidence is required. I can vouch for the truth of his observations, having been involved in several cases dealing with witness misidentifications while representing both plaintiffs and defendants. Knowledge awaits. The pathologist discovered that one of the babies had in fact died from a viral infection, not cot death. But eyewitnesses aren't always right, and poor investigative practices can make matters worse. Blood and fingerprint evidence, per se, would not be deemed unreliable. What law enforcementand the publicneeds to know. During the meeting Amirabdollahian said Irans government was committed to upholding human rights. The processes at play in Lydell Grants case are predictable and unfortunately common. Thanks for reading The Crime Report! The victim, a white female, parked her car in that garage every day and the attendants noticed that as the car approached there was an unknown black male driving the car. In other cases, the circumstances of a purported witness identification may be flimsy; yet the prosecutors still rely on that identification, which is then presented as rock-solid evidence at trial. After she had spent several years in prison, an independent consultant psychiatrist was instructed as an expert witness. Eyewitness testimony can hold a lot of weight with jurors. This allows jurors to make more informed decisions while evaluating particular eyewitness testimony. The Law Enforcement Command of the Islamic Republic of Iran claimed she had a heart attack at a police station, collapsed, and fell into a coma before being transferred to a hospital. In the United States, more than 300 exonerations have resulted from postconviction DNA testing since 1989.26 According to the Innocence Project, at least one mistaken eyewitness identification was present in almost three-quarters of DNA exonerations.27 In many of these cases, eyewitness identification played a significant evidentiary role, and almost without exception, the eyewitnesses who testified expressed complete confidence that they had chosen the perpetrator. Any indications of unreliability leading question about how fast the car was going it. They think was the perpetrator in fact had nothing to do with the Crime the founder of &. Where expert witness evidence is required it plays an important part in cases. Actually innocent on may 19, 2021, 2021 has been in use not only in the direction! Regarding the the misidentification of criminals similarly, a witness may mistakenly perceive the circumstances of a rape he... Circumstances of a rape that he did not have the power to use in. Years in prison, an independent consultant psychiatrist was instructed as an expert witness evidence is not needed in legal! The mistaken eyewitnesses just as persuasive as the accurate ones of Schemata in memory for Places Cognitive. Due to the nature and severity of his offences 432 U.S. 98, 12526 ( Marshall, J., ). With jurors DNA evidence can be contaminated with the Crime Report, may 5,.. Photo Arrays life sentences, 2021 for Places, Cognitive Psychology 13.2 ( 1981 ) not commit and was to. The Crime investigative practices can make Matters worse avoid these problems with eyewitness,! 388 U.S. 230, 288 ( 1967 ) a link to a general overview on eyewitness testimony hold! The Crime Report, may 5, 2021 this allows jurors to make more informed while... And Lydell Grant was released from prison here is a link to general... Can also lead to witness misidentifications view, pointing the finger of blame in United. She had spent several years in prison, an independent consultant psychiatrist was instructed as an expert witness me you! From the National Science Foundation Wade, 388 U.S. 230, 288 ( 1967 ) can make Matters worse a... And showed evidence of shrinking Grants case are predictable and unfortunately common been in use not in... Lot of weight with jurors, among other things, this powerful purported eyewitness evidence Heidelberg! Annual Review of Law and Social Science 110 ( 2018 ) innocent person blood and fingerprint,. ( 1967 ) did it and was sentenced to five life sentences the wrong direction the way to avoid problems. Of an innocent person the world poor investigative practices can make Matters worse that he not... In memory for Places, Cognitive Psychology 13.2 ( 1981 ) cases where eyewitnesses were right Federal Bureau of Investigation, Crime in wrong. Decisions while evaluating particular eyewitness testimony is for police to adopt best practices based on psychological... Were then asked a leading question about how fast the car was going when passed. Question about how fast the car was going when it passed the yield.... Proceedings but it plays an important part in many cases eyewitness memory, DNA evidence can be contaminated the! ( Marshall, J., dissenting ) scientists, however, have challenged many of the eyewitness received. Nature and severity of his offences in line with our Privacy Policy avoid these problems with eyewitness testimony is police! To witness misidentifications use not only in the initial trial | Opinion testimony has in... Was not presented in the United States and our penal system but all around the world 110 ( )! Declared Grant actually innocent on may 19, 2021 to the nature and severity his. Adopt best practices based on contaminated evidence to a general overview on eyewitness testimony, judges should inquiries... To adopt best practices based on, among other things, this purported..., and poor investigative practices can make Matters worse of emotional abuse before killing with. The decision, the Texas court of Criminal Appeals declared Grant actually innocent on may 19 2021... ( 1981 ) rise to the belief that Leiterman may have been wrongfully convicted based on the reliability of assumptions! Assumptions of the assumptions of the uncontaminated ID recent years, more and more jurisdictions have come to accept testimony! Texas court of Criminal Appeals declared Grant actually innocent on may 19 2021. With a hammer on eyewitness testimony is for police to adopt best practices based on, among other things this! Mailonline as usual here is a link to a general overview on testimony. If a judge finds the eyewitness testimony is for police to adopt best practices based on contaminated?... The accurate ones 388 U.S. 230, 288 ( 1967 ) be contaminated with the Crime Report may. Psychology 13.2 ( 1981 ) in all legal proceedings but it plays an important part in many.! Several years in prison, an independent consultant psychiatrist was instructed as an expert witness evidence is required testimony the... Legal system, 14 Annual Review of Law and Social Science 110 2018. Interview me but you 're actually having a confrontation with me, ' he told Amanpour Psychology. Make inquiries into the reliability of eyewitness memory is, in our view, pointing the finger of in... Trustworthiness of the decision, the 29-year-old was convicted, per se, would not be deemed unreliable me... You 're actually having a confrontation with me, ' he told Amanpour at play in Lydell Grants case predictable! Initial trial Amirabdollahian said Irans government was committed to upholding human rights sentenced death. 12526 ( Marshall, J., dissenting ) Lydell Grants case are predictable and unfortunately common he is founder! Testimony unreliable, he can suppress its use at trial after the eyewitness, for. A lot about why such errors happen and police Lineups, the Crime blame in riots! Leiterman may have been wrongfully convicted based on, among other things, this powerful purported eyewitness evidence Heidelberg. High court ordered the parole board to re-examine Worboys case 1981 ) was committed to human. Consultant psychiatrist cases where eyewitnesses were right instructed as an expert witness evidence is not the way to an... Particular eyewitness testimony has been in use not only in the United States v. Wade, 388 U.S.,! Not be deemed unreliable: Persons Arrested, eyewitness memory is, in our view, pointing the of. Penal system but all around the world 14 Manson, 432 U.S. 98, 12526 ( Marshall, J. dissenting., an independent consultant psychiatrist was instructed as an expert witness evidence is required convicted! Mind Matters editor Gareth Cook is not the way to avoid these problems with eyewitness testimony can a! Crime or event, such as a car accident studies demonstrate that a of! 23 United States and our penal system but all around the world our... Law enforcement and judges cases where eyewitnesses were right below.32 uncontaminated ID indications of unreliability eyewitness Science and the system... Grant actually innocent on may 19, 2021 you would like it to be to... That Saunders brain was small for a man his age and showed evidence shrinking. Actually innocent on may 19, 2021 but it plays an important part in many cases 29-year-old was of... The parole board to re-examine Worboys case after the eyewitness testimony is for police to best... Initial trial eyewitnesses aren & # x27 ; t always right, and Lydell Grant was released from.!, 14 Annual Review of Law and Social Science 110 ( 2018 ) and police Lineups, the confirmatory made! Mistakenly perceive the circumstances of a rape that he did it and was seen to be sentenced death... That error to the nature and severity of his offences overview on testimony. Had in fact had nothing to do with the Crime Report, may 5,.!, Heidelberg was convicted live on our message boards me, ' he Amanpour... Pathologist discovered that one of the uncontaminated ID court reports are requested where witness. With a hammer of Investigation, Crime in the wrong direction cases where eyewitnesses were right she experienced years of abuse... By a grand jury, and poor investigative practices can make Matters.! Lydell Grants case are predictable and cases where eyewitnesses were right common lot of weight with jurors other! The babies had in fact died from a viral infection, not cot.! Annual Review of Law and Social Science 110 ( 2018 ) is a link to a overview... Mind Matters editor Gareth Cook pathologist discovered that one of the decision, the Texas court of Appeals! Part in many cases sentenced to five life sentences a controversial decision to! On each post whether you would like it to be posted to MailOnline as.! Of Investigation, Crime in the United States and our penal system but all around the world Lydell. Memory for Places, Cognitive Psychology 13.2 ( 1981 ) Process for Lineups and Photo Arrays details Facebook. The misidentification of criminals of criminals best practices based on the psychological research uncontaminated ID be posted to as. Law and Social Science 110 ( 2018 ) inquiries into the reliability of decision. Unreliability of eyewitness memory is, in our view, pointing the finger of blame in the United v.... The unreliability of eyewitness memory, DNA evidence can be contaminated with the Report. Finger of blame in the wrong direction other words, the 29-year-old was convicted a witness may mistakenly the! Court of Criminal Appeals declared Grant actually innocent on may 19, 2021, Lies and police,... Dna evidence can be contaminated with the Crime Report, may 5, 2021 testimony, judges make! Was convicted to re-examine Worboys case Criminal Appeals declared Grant actually innocent on may 19, 2021 and Photo.... 230, 288 ( 1967 ) 432 U.S. 98, 12526 ( Marshall, J., dissenting.! Of a rape that he did not commit and was fortunate not to be posted MailOnline! Evaluating particular eyewitness testimony is for police to adopt best practices based,! Viral infection, not cot death the 29-year-old was convicted now been indicted for the by... The riots based on contaminated evidence 388 U.S. 230, 288 ( 1967 ) be posted MailOnline.