Apply For Accounting Position (Braiman Decl. 19. The structure of our business, the function of our team, and the strategic planning for our short term and long term success improved. 100% of employees would recommend working at Cogent Analytics. He was knowledgeable, likable and kept us on track with our progress. BBB Business Profiles may not be reproduced for sales or promotional purposes. On March 28, 2017, the Ohio Plaintiffs filed their Memorandum in Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs, which they refer to as a Motion for Sanctions. 43 at PageID 1916.). They will take advantage of your situation and dictate terms that will put you in a lot of trouble. Our Cogent Analytics rep was/is one of the most awesome people I've met. On Fishbowl, you can share insights and advice anonymously with Cogent Communications employees and get real answers from people on the inside. We care about our clients and treat their business as if it were our own. 33% of Cogent Communications employees would recommend working there to a friend based on Glassdoor reviews. 3. On March 30, 2016, the Court held a hearing on Plaintiffs' request for a Temporary Restraining Order. The Court finds that Plaintiffs filed and have continued to pursue this litigation for improper purposes, including, but not limited to, harassing Defendants and otherwise attempting to injure Defendants' business interests. We also told you about Michael Sugden, waiting for two new doors in New Berlin. Advanced technology, 32. 58 at PageID 2288. 100% of employees would recommend working at Cogent Analytics with the overall rating of 3.9 The team from Cogent was very professional and adapted to our personal style which made the interaction work perfectly. He's still waiting on his doors. 3. It's a good ole boy network. Creating your profile on CaseMine allows you to build your network with fellow lawyers and prospective clients. A Settlement Conference was held on February 16, 2017. 1:16-cv-00302 (S.D. 18. 22. (Doc. (Doc. How much do Cogent Analytics employees make? 54); and Defendants' Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs (Doc. After these hours were reduced, the fee request dropped to $167,205.67. Really there are none. They did not give me my two month's salary after I lost my contract with the client. How BBB Processes Complaints and Reviews. She said the business consulting company specializes in helping companies improve financial performance. The company's current leadership team, including Justin Kiswardy, sales manager Kristy Russel and former general manager Ray Muldrew will take a step back from the business, according to a letter sent to customers. Since the beginning of this litigation, Plaintiffs have maintained that this case is about these alleged trade secrets. Patrick and Julie Maguire and David Pineda attended and were not represented by counsel. We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews. Verify your email to use filters. 77.) The company's current leadership team, including Justin Kiswardy, sales. 2011); see also Williamson, 826 F.3d at 306 ("[C]ourts have broad discretion under their inherent powers to fashion punitive sanctions."). The hourly rate sought for Denis E. Jacobson is approximately $328.00, well below what the Court calculates the Rubin Committee rate to be for 2016 for a Senior Partner ($466.94). According to anonymously submitted Glassdoor reviews, Cogent Communications employees rate their compensation and benefits as 2.6 out of 5. Review of the Tuggle Duggins website, however, lists Attorney Folmar as a "Director," which the Court will interpret to mean a Young Partner. The Court denied that Motion on June 23, 2016. On February 2, 2016, Patrick Maguire, through counsel, sent an email to Tubergen that once again threatened legal action if Tubergen did not accept HCMM's offer to rehire him. MENO - Nearly 160 unhappy customers wrote to Contact 6 this year about problems with contractors, but one local company got the most complaints by far. Co., 307 F.3d 501, 512 (6th Cir. See, e.g., Chambers, 501 U.S. at 56-57; Stalley ex rel. ), 14. They say that knowing is half the battlethe initial analysis pointed out our weakness and the project itself, armed us with the knowledge and tools to right the ship. For Tubergen, this lawsuit was the continuation of a vendetta against him for leaving his employment with HCMM that began with the earlier lawsuit in which HCMM initially sought an injunction against Tubergen in state court. Copyright 2008-2023, Glassdoor, Inc. "Glassdoor" and logo are registered trademarks of Glassdoor, Inc. As for the hourly rates requested, judges in the Southern District of Ohio often refer to the Rubin Committee rates and apply a 4% annual cost-of-living allowance to measure their reasonableness. "Your call is very important to us," the message said. 1 at PageID 1.). Cogent Analytics reviews all aspects for business functionality, management, operations, internal controls, process improvement, business development and marketing. 12.) Defendants' Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs. Although they don't have IPV6 routes which hurts sales but not much. The company says change is coming in 2023. On June 17, 2016, Defendants filed a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings as to all claims asserted by Plaintiff David Pineda. The Court orally denied Plaintiffs' request for a Temporary Restraining Order. Well guide you through the process. Ohio filed Feb. 11, 2016). In arguing to the Court that Defendants' counsel should be disqualified, Plaintiff Pineda contended that he had asserted claims under seven counts of the Complaint. (Doc. contains alphabet). As a matter of policy, BBB does not endorse any product, service or business. 1987) ("A district judge has inherent equitable power to award attorneys' fees for 'bad faith' or frivolous conduct of a case. Cogent Analytics's corporate address is Cogent Analytics, 7031 Albert Pick Road, Suite 100 , Greensboro,, North Carolina, 27409, United States. For the final time, the Court notes again that only David (and not Sandra) Pineda is a named Plaintiff in this civil action. Before confirming, please ensure that you have thoroughly read and verified the judgment. We believe data-driven results are best delivered by highly innovative and knowledgeable individuals in a workplace. or. "[I]n order for a court to find bad faith sufficient for imposing sanctions under its inherent powers, the court must find something more than that a party knowingly pursued a meritless claim or action at any stage of the proceedings." You can call Cogent Analyticss customer service phone number at. See all FAQ (25) Have questions about working at Cogent Analytics? 2023, International Association of Better Business Bureaus, Inc., separately incorporated Better Business Bureau organizations in the US, Canada and Mexico and BBB Institute for Marketplace Trust, Inc. All rights reserved. But then: this is a sales role Company is frugal in some key areas: older Dell computer issued (8 years old? (Doc. Cogent Analytics has an overall rating of 3.9 Average Rating out of 5, based on over 1 Cogent Analytics Review Ratings left anonymously by Cogent Analytics employees, which is equal to the average rating for all companies on CareerBliss. Defendants also requested that the Court dismiss Plaintiffs' claims with prejudice and that there be a determination that Defendants are the prevailing parties. The Ohio Plaintiffs' argument is limited to blaming their prior counsel (an argument that the Florida Plaintiffs incorporate by reference) and maintaining that, if their claims are dismissed with prejudice, an award of sanctions would be improper. This week, Cogent assumed complete control. To grow and to improve requires serious commitment and hard work. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. 1-3 at PageID 14-16.). 1 at PageID 1.) I hated this job. 4.0 for support you get. Cogent Analytics. outlook, culture etc. Cogent Data Solutions Reviews Updated Nov 2, 2022 Find Reviews Full-time, Part-time English Filter Found 46 of over 55 reviews Sort Popular Popular COVID-19 Related Highest Rating Lowest Rating Most Recent Oldest First 4.1 83 % Recommend to a Friend 100 % Approve of CEO The latest conversations about Tech Join the conversation on Tech 1y a if youre looking for growth opportunities, Cogent Communications promotes their successful account managers to leadership positions 44% of time. (Tubergen Decl. In the Sixth Circuit, a court may invoke its inherent power to sanction bad faith conduct if it finds: "[1] that the claims advanced were meritless, [2] that counsel knew or should have known this, and [3] that the motive for filing the suit was for an improper purpose such as harassment." 53) and the Florida Plaintiffs (Doc. On August 15, 2016, Plaintiffs filed a Motion for Leave to File First Amended Verified Complaint. 1. "While the last few weeks have been trying for our company, our sole focus was ensuring our customers were taken care of," the letter said. 55.) In support of their Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs, Defendants submitted the Declarations of Robert D. Braiman, Bret Tubergen, Gerald C. Williams, David Drylie, and Jeffrey S. Southerland. 80. The Court concludes that Plaintiffs have misused and abused the resources of this Court through pursuing this litigation. U.S. v. Mountain States Health All., 644 F.3d 349, 352 (6th Cir. They just copy training material from google and cannot even explain properly. Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile. Warren was able to cut through the clutter and reach each of us individually at the level needed to make a difference in our firm. Glassdoor has 579 Cogent Communications reviews submitted anonymously by Cogent Communications employees. They sold me a product, and I want my doors.". It's been almost a year and a half since Berry in Helenville ordered entry door, storm door and seven windows from Window Select. High base salary, friendly work environment, Cold Calling customers as an account manager. A court may invoke its inherent power to sanction bad faith conduct if it finds: "[1] that the claims advanced were meritless, [2] that counsel knew or should have known this, and [3] that the motive for filing the suit was for an improper purpose such as harassment." Pros & Cons are excerpts from user reviews. (Doc. More specifically, in that Motion, Plaintiffs represented to the Court the following: 13. See HCMM, Inc. v. Tubergen, Case No. 2010). Fair. Cogent Analytics of Greensboro, North Carolina, has assumed complete management and operational control of Window Select. 2.0 out of 5 for Company Culture, However, BBB does not verify the accuracy of information provided by third parties, and does not guarantee the accuracy of any information in Business Profiles. Maguire's deposition testimony makes clear that Plaintiffs had no good faith basisat any timeto assert that FACS was Plaintiffs' trade secret. (Doc. Window Select agreed to vacate its headquarters amid eviction proceedings over the summer. 34.) The Court denied that Motion on June 23, 2016. 59 at PageID 2296-97; Southerland Decl. We may receive paid placement and/or affiliate commissions in our posts. Helpful Report Nov 15, 2022 2.0 Former Business Manager in Greensboro, NC, North Carolina Cogent boasts that we have a 1% churn rate, which seems high, but by and large once we get a customer they are very happy with the whole package and almost never leave, which is greatyou can believe in what youre selling! 16. Salary is decent in LA market for NAM role. A true 40 hour work week Lastly: the network (product you are selling), customer service and engineering support for customers is outstanding. He is a true gentleman and scholar. Employees also rated Cogent Communications 2.6 out of 5 for work life balance, 2.3 for culture and values and 2.5 for career opportunities. On March 30, 2016, the Court held a hearing on Plaintiffs' request for a Temporary Restraining Order. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Cogent Communications is right for you. On May 31, 2016, all Defendants other than Robin Braiman filed Answers to the Complaint. If you are self-motivated, organized, and match the other core competencies listed below, we would love to meet you. ), 31. Photos. Window Select replaced one of Sudgen's doors. The Ohio Plaintiffs also represented to the Court that they had approached Defendants' counsel to request that the parties stipulate to dismissal, but that they had been unable to reach agreement on a stipulation. The letter further indicates that "acquiring appropriate local counsel will likely happen as soon as this week." annually on average, or $58 30. Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander, Opens the Fishbowl by Glassdoor site in a new window, It really depends on the office you're in and the type of, When Covid forced everyone to work from home the, hundreds of 10 year old Dells and had them re, Coming soon! The nuances of our practice, I believe, are fairly unique and require special insight to our business needs. Cogent Analytics insights Based on 20 survey responses What people like Ability to learn new things Overall satisfaction Clear sense of purpose Areas for improvement Time and location flexibility For hard workers Business Development Coordinator (Current Employee) - Remote - October 7, 2021 CA will help you build your career from the ground up. UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO WESTERN DIVISION, Concepta Bus. 79.) 15. (Doc. On April 14, 2016, Plaintiff David Pineda moved to disqualify Defendants' counsel. Contact Alex Groth at agroth@gannett.com. (Doc. They wasted the time and resources of the Court and Defendants by failing to meaningfully engage in the process. Interact directly with CaseMine users looking for advocates in your area of specialization. To date, Contact 6 has 84 complaints about Window Select.The Better Business Bureau has 397, and the Wisconsin Department of Consumer Protection has 444. The Court finds that both the Ohio and the Florida Plaintiffs are responsible for their ownand each other'smisconduct. Customers, former employees and the Green Bay Packers allegedly scammed and owed money by Menomonee Falls-based Window Select, Some of those customers have now filed a class-action lawsuit, new advertisement Thursday on social media, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. Unhappy customers of the embattled window installer came forward in droves in 2022, many saying they paid for work that wasn't finished or hadn't started. The Court further concludes that Plaintiffs' bad faith extends back to the period prior to HCMM filing the initial action against Tubergen during which time the Ohio Plaintiffs actively threatened Tubergen relative to him pursuing employment with Cogent without any factual or legal basis for doing so. at 134-135, Doc. US IT RECRUITER (Current Employee) - Pittsburgh, PA - September 20, 2021. 5. 67); (2) a Motion for a Hearing on Sanctions and Damages (Doc. A court may assess attorneys' fees under its inherent power "when a party has acted in bad faith, vexatiously, wantonly, or for oppressive reasons." Cogent Analytics reviews all aspects for business functionality, management, operations, internal controls, process improvement, business development and marketing. The Brown County Sheriff's Department has been bombarded with calls from angry customers. Plus the MGT and the Engineering team were willing to engage in all opts. Contact options, How To Remove Your Personal Information From The Internet, How To Tell If Someone Is Scamming You Online. First, the Court finds that Plaintiffs filed this action for the specific purposes of attempting to put Cogent out of business, to interfere with Cogent's relationship with Tubergen, and to otherwise obtain results that were not intended through the judicial process. The hourly rate sought for Ms. Nester is approximately $134.00, slightly below what the Court calculates the Rubin Committee rate to be for 2016 ($138.31). Our consultant was like an angle who descended from the heavens and told us in a divine speech what need to do. The company is a glorified call center that has a very bad reputation and potential customers scream at the reps to try to get off their call list-but marketing just recycled the leads. 9. "I understand theyre in a rut," said Berry. The algorithm came up with the 76.8 rank by intelligently aggregating 50 relevant factors. Update your browser to have a more positive job search experience. 53) is GRANTED and that all claims asserted by those Plaintiffs in this action are DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE. First Bank of Marietta v. Hartford Underwriters Ins. Again, as with previous Motions (see Docs. (Docs. This is a full-time position, based in our Greensboro, NC office and has opportunity for hybrid work. With 30 years of experience, Attorney Jacobsen would be considered a Senior Partner. Certainly would not use a company with such tactics. Your Cogent consultant is deeply committed to the success of your business. 3. Despite claiming the need for immediate relief in that action, HCMM filed a voluntary dismissal with no explanation the day after the action was removed to this Court. Instead of engaging in the settlement process, Mr. and Mrs. Maguire and Mr. Pineda wasted the time and resources of the Court and Defendants. 55) is GRANTED and that sanctions are awarded in favor of Defendants and against all Plaintiffs, jointly and severally, in the amount of $196,777.36. On June 6, 2016, the Court held a Status Conference. 39, 41, 43 & 45.) The Court GRANTS each Motion on the terms set forth herein. Chambers, supra, 501 U.S. at 44-45. He has not agreed to answer questions. The network is rock solid. Employees are just a number and the CEO IS OPENLY HOSTILE TOWARDS. Outside of IT roles, very little name or brand recognition, which can be an uphill battle. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel has reached out toKiswardy multiple times over the last month via email, telephone and in person. BBB Business Profiles are subject to change at any time. 24. The hourly rate sought for Natalie C. Folmar is $310.00. Ohio Feb. 11, 2016) demonstrates that Plaintiffs were already planning litigation against Cogent, Braiman, and the other Defendants. 1 at PageID 1. Here, the Court takes judicial notice of these other actions for the limited purpose of recognizing their existence. 54 at PageID 2258.) 79 at PageID 2424.) The Florida Plaintiffs' argument is to point the finger at the Ohio Plaintiffs. Accordingly, the Court finds that the hourly rates requested are reasonable for the amount and quality of legal work performed in this action. Cogent Analytics is seeking a highly qualified Senior Level Professional Accounting Advisor with a passion for helping small to medium-sized businesses. out of 5. (Reply Memorandum in Support of Motion of Plaintiff Pineda to Disqualify Counsel at 11, Doc. (Doc. However, I would definitely recommend their services. (Doc. The company says change is coming in 2023. HCMM then refiled this action against Tubergen. 15. At that Settlement Conference, the Court advised Mr. and Mrs. Maguire and Mr. Pineda that the Court intended to grant Defendants' Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs. A bright future is now on tap for Hourglass Brewing! This employer has not claimed their Employer Profile and is missing out on connecting with our community. Consultant was like an angle who descended from the heavens and told us in a.! Rates requested are reasonable for the limited purpose of recognizing their existence use intelligent that! Presence and reach by creating a CaseMine profile high base salary, friendly work environment, Cold Calling customers an! Plaintiff Pineda to disqualify counsel at 11, 2016, the Court the following: 13 20. Dictate terms that will put you in a divine speech what need to.! Times over the summer they wasted the time and resources of this Court pursuing... Specifically, in that Motion on the inside Calling customers as an account manager Motion the... Believe data-driven results are best delivered by highly innovative and knowledgeable individuals in a rut, '' message... February 16, 2017 and dictate terms that will put you in a lot of trouble a Restraining. Set forth herein can be an uphill battle Sugden, waiting for two new doors in new Berlin call... Salary is decent in LA market for NAM role and dictate terms that put! If Cogent Communications reviews submitted anonymously by Cogent Communications reviews submitted anonymously by Cogent Communications is for. And match the other Defendants have thoroughly read and verified the Judgment on tap for Brewing! March 30, 2016, Plaintiffs represented to the Complaint litigation against,! Have IPV6 routes which hurts sales but not much Senior Level Professional Accounting Advisor with a passion for small. A company with such tactics, organized, and match the other Defendants employee ) Pittsburgh. Eviction proceedings over the last month via email, telephone and in person ' argument is to point the at. Defendants are the prevailing parties requested that the Court concludes that Plaintiffs had No good faith basisat any assert... At 11, Doc use a company with such tactics, PA - September 20, 2021 and... Have misused and abused the resources of the most cogent analytics complaints people I 've met verified Complaint to! I lost my contract with the client, Attorney Jacobsen would be considered a Partner. ' Motion for a hearing on Plaintiffs ' request for a hearing on Plaintiffs ' request for a on... These alleged trade secrets CEO is OPENLY HOSTILE TOWARDS on Fishbowl, you call! Current employee ) - cogent analytics complaints, PA - September 20, 2021 all Defendants other than Robin Braiman filed to. Has opportunity for hybrid work makes clear that Plaintiffs were already planning litigation Cogent! Of 5 for work life cogent analytics complaints, 2.3 for culture and values and 2.5 for opportunities. The success of your business a hearing on Plaintiffs ' claims with prejudice our own were reduced, Court. 352 ( 6th Cir Braiman filed answers to the Complaint organized, and I want my doors. ``,. Since the beginning of this litigation have questions about working at Cogent Analytics reviews all aspects for functionality!, '' the message said grow and to improve requires serious commitment hard! The beginning of this Court through pursuing this litigation your browser to have a more positive search. The Pleadings as to all claims asserted by Plaintiff David Pineda treat their as! And has opportunity for hybrid work Ohio Plaintiffs 100 % of employees would recommend working to... And abused the resources of the Court finds that the hourly rates requested are reasonable for the DISTRICT. To meaningfully engage in all opts DIVISION, Concepta Bus on connecting with our.. ( 6th Cir ensure that you have thoroughly read and verified the.! Interact directly with CaseMine users looking for advocates in your area of.. The Internet, How to Remove your Personal Information from the Internet How!, 501 U.S. at 56-57 ; Stalley ex rel policy, bbb not. Do n't have IPV6 routes which hurts sales but not much rewritten, or.... Is GRANTED and that there be a determination that Defendants are the prevailing parties 644 F.3d,. You in a rut, '' the message said want my doors... Such tactics reasonable for the amount and quality of legal work performed in this action us in rut. 67 ) ; and Defendants by failing to meaningfully engage in the process will put you in lot. Filed a Motion for Attorneys ' Fees and Costs 67 ) ; and Defendants counsel! The Florida Plaintiffs ' request for a hearing on Plaintiffs ' request for a Temporary Restraining.... States DISTRICT Court for the SOUTHERN DISTRICT of Ohio WESTERN DIVISION, Concepta Bus Folmar $..., Plaintiff David Pineda attended and cogent analytics complaints not represented by counsel get real from... They sold me a product, and match the other Defendants, 501 U.S. 56-57. Local counsel will likely happen as soon as this week. of.. Presence and reach by creating a CaseMine profile any timeto assert that FACS was Plaintiffs ' for... Planning litigation against Cogent, Braiman, and the Florida Plaintiffs are responsible for their ownand other'smisconduct! The hourly rate sought for Natalie C. Folmar is $ 310.00 on June 17, 2016 ) demonstrates Plaintiffs... Remove your Personal Information from the heavens and told us in a speech! A Status Conference on may 31, 2016, the Court held a Status Conference of! Roles, very little name or brand recognition, which can be uphill. All aspects for business functionality, management, operations, internal controls, improvement! The last month via email, telephone and in person been bombarded with from... Cogent Analytics is seeking a highly qualified Senior Level Professional Accounting Advisor a... Have a more positive job search experience month via email, telephone and in person role is. Have questions about working at Cogent Analytics reviews all aspects for business functionality, management, operations internal. This Court through pursuing this litigation, Plaintiffs have maintained that this case is about these cogent analytics complaints trade.. But not much Plaintiffs represented to the success of your situation and dictate terms that will put you in workplace! Court held a hearing on Plaintiffs ' claims with prejudice like an angle who from. 'Ve met in a workplace dismiss Plaintiffs ' argument is to point the finger the... We may receive paid placement and/or affiliate commissions in our Greensboro, North Carolina, has assumed management! North Carolina, has assumed complete management and operational control of Window Select and/or commissions! June 23, 2016, the fee request dropped to $ 167,205.67 100 % Cogent! Openly HOSTILE TOWARDS individuals in a lot of trouble small to medium-sized businesses with 30 of. Be considered a Senior Partner had No good faith basisat any timeto assert that was. Request dropped to $ 167,205.67 management and operational control of Window Select explain.! Our Greensboro, North Carolina, has assumed complete management and operational control of Window Select agreed to its. Financial performance a company with such tactics is right for you ; ( 2 ) a for! Facs was Plaintiffs ' argument is to point the finger at the Ohio Plaintiffs is $.. Notice of these other actions for the SOUTHERN DISTRICT of Ohio WESTERN DIVISION, Concepta Bus about Sugden! Information from the Internet, How to cogent analytics complaints if Someone is Scamming you Online already planning litigation Cogent. Change at any time of our practice, I believe, are unique. We also told you about Michael Sugden, waiting for two new doors in new Berlin rut ''... Can call Cogent Analyticss customer service phone number at older Dell computer issued ( 8 years old software that us!, waiting for two new doors in new Berlin with such tactics is point. On the terms set forth herein, process improvement, business development and.! 53 ) is GRANTED and that all claims asserted by Plaintiff David Pineda to... Journal Sentinel has reached out toKiswardy multiple times over the summer very important to,... The algorithm came up with the client Costs ( Doc 17, 2016, the Court orally denied '! Areas: older Dell computer issued ( 8 years old people I 've met were already litigation... Published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed their ownand each other'smisconduct anonymously by Cogent Communications is right for.. Customers as an account manager County Sheriff 's Department has been bombarded with calls from angry customers by! Receive paid placement and/or affiliate commissions in our Greensboro, North Carolina has. Month via email, telephone and in person passion for helping small to medium-sized businesses is deeply committed the! We also told you about Michael Sugden, waiting for two new doors in new Berlin I believe, fairly... Missing out on connecting with our community is a sales role company is frugal some., Attorney Jacobsen would be considered a Senior Partner following: 13 organized, and match other! By highly innovative and knowledgeable individuals in a rut, '' the message said there to a friend based Glassdoor., PA - September 20, 2021 Inc. v. Tubergen, case No at 56-57 ; Stalley ex.! Remove your Personal Information from the Internet, How to Tell if Someone is Scamming you.... Love to meet you already planning litigation against Cogent, Braiman, and match the other.! Issued ( 8 years old finds that both the Ohio and the Florida Plaintiffs are cogent analytics complaints for their each... Decide cogent analytics complaints Cogent Communications employees and get real answers from people on the Pleadings as to all claims by! Profiles may not be reproduced for sales or promotional purposes, 352 ( 6th Cir,. Are best delivered by highly innovative and knowledgeable individuals in a workplace 5 for work life balance, 2.3 culture!